In Rosgonki ANO v Formula One World Championship Ltd [2026] EWHC 2899 (Comm), Andrew Baker J accepted the arguments made by the Claimant (represented by Frederick Alliott) that the so-called ‘Crabtree’ principle – namely, that the Court may refuse to order security for costs in respect of a claim where the same issues arise on a counterclaim in the same proceedings – applied to the facts of the case, albeit that the Judge decided that partial security was appropriate in respect of certain issues (relating to defences based on sanctions) which were raised only by the claim.

The proceedings concern Rosgonki’s claim for repayment of approximately US$24 million following cancellation of the Russian Grand Prix, and F1’s substantially larger counterclaim.

During the course of his judgment, the Judge analysed the relevance and applicability of so-called ‘Dumrul’ undertakings to consent to the dismissal of the counterclaim if the claim is dismissed for failure to provide security, named after the decision of Hamblen J in Dumrul v Standard Chartered Bank [2010] EWHC 2625 (Comm). Accepting the submissions of the Claimant, the Judge rejected the proposition that such an undertaking necessarily resolves the principled concern underlying Crabtree: that an order securing the costs of defending a claim should not, in substance, secure the defendant’s costs of pursuing its own counterclaim. A Dumrul undertaking addresses the prospect of one-sided litigation, but leaves the principled concern unanswered.

The contrary assumption in Dumrul rested on a concession which the Judge considered incorrect. He criticised the reasoning in Explosive Learning Solutions v Landmarc [2023] EWHC 1263 (Comm) and Cedar Mundi v Attieh [2025] EWHC 1930 (Comm) (two other first instance decisions where a Dumrul undertaking was accepted as solving the Crabtree objection), stating that, if not distinguishable, those decisions should not be followed; and preferred the obiter reasoning of Moore-Bick LJ in Anglo Irish Asset Finance plc v Flood [2011] EWCA Civ 799.

The decision provides useful guidance on both the limits of Dumrul undertakings and the identification of costs properly eligible for security.

Frederick Alliott is instructed by Branch Austin McCormick LLP on behalf of the Claimant (Rosgonki).

A copy of the judgment can be found here.